Friday, November 19, 2010

Slain Officer Remembered as a "Cop's Cop"! (By Janet Zimmerman, Mark Muckenfuss, Alicia Robinson, and Brian Rokos) Nov. 17, 2010

Slain officer remembered as a 'cop's cop'


  Download story podcast

08:10 AM PST on Wednesday, November 17, 2010

By JANET ZIMMERMAN, MARK MUCKENFUSS, ALICIA ROBINSON and BRIAN ROKOS
The Press-Enterprise

Final goodbyes as Officer Bonaminio is laid to rest
Final goodbyes as Officer Bonaminio is laid to rest
Published: 11/16/2010 08:01 PM

Video: Memorial for Officer Bonaminio


Photo Gallery: Ryan Bonaminio Funeral Service

Fallen Riverside police Officer Ryan Bonaminio was given a hero's goodbye Tuesday in a poignant service marked by standing ovations, military salutes and countless tears.

Thousands of law enforcement officers from as far away as Las Vegas and Sonoma turned out for the two-hour memorial at the Grove Community Church in Riverside, followed by a service at Riverside National Cemetery.

From the time the officer's flag-draped casket left the mortuary in the morning until it reached its final resting place almost five hours later, it was accompanied by a lengthy procession of patrol cars and motorcycles, their lights flashing.

Story continues below
slain Riverside police Officer Ryan Bonominio memorial
Stan Lim/The Press-Enterprise
Riverside Police Department personnel form a cordon of honor as the casket of slain Riverside police Officer Ryan Bonaminio arrives at Riverside National Cemetery in Riverside. Police Chaplain Steve Ballinger likened Bonaminio's life to a leg of a relay race: "He has placed that baton of life in our hands with his attitude. ... Ryan would say," 'Run.' "

The young man with the ever-present smile was remembered as a loving son and brother, an unusually focused and prepared soldier during two Army tours in the Middle East and, by his chief, as a "cop's cop" whose short four years on the force could serve as an example to his colleagues.

"Ryan knew from a young age he was supposed to be a great police officer. He fulfilled his purpose on earth. How many of us live two or three times as long ... without knowing our purpose?" Riverside Police Chief Sergio Diaz said in an emotional eulogy. "Ryan has taught us how to live. With his death he inspires each of us to be better."

Bonamino's slaying 10 days ago -- police say probably with his own weapon by a hit-and-run suspect he had pursued -- has produced a deep reaction among officers and residents. His funeral drew a standing-room-only crowd of about 6,000, some of them friends, most of them strangers.

Officers and deputies came from throughout the state to pay homage to their brother. They said his death has put them on heightened alert about what can go wrong.

"We all do the same job. It could be any of us in the same situation," said a red-eyed Tiffany Emon, a San Bernardino police officer.

Hundreds of onlookers lined streets outside the church and on the route to the cemetery. Some parents kept their children out of school to watch the procession. They waved blue balloons and American flags and held homemade signs, including one that said: "Goodbye hero. We honor you. Thank you."

At the cemetery, a 21-gun volley and the playing of taps were followed by a folding ceremony for the flag draping Bonaminio's casket. The flag was then placed in his mother's hands.

'RYAN IS FREE'

Bonamino, 27, was shot on the night of Nov. 7. After he pulled over a stolen tractor-trailer cab, its driver jumped out and fled into Riverside's Fairmount Park. Bonaminio ran after him and was attacked and shot.

Earl Ellis Green, 44, of Rubidoux, was arrested two days later and Bonaminio's weapon was found during a search of places Green frequented. He has been charged with murder and is eligible for the death penalty. Green is in custody pending a psychological assessment. His arraignment is set for Dec. 16.

Story continues below
slain Riverside police Officer Ryan Bonominio memorial
Mark Zaleski/The Press-Enterprise
Officer Bonaminio's father, Joe, spends a farewell moment at his son's casket during the burial ceremony at Riverside National Cemetery.

Bonaminio's mother, Gerri, shook her head and wiped her tears as the casket was moved from the hearse to the church. Bonaminio's fellow officers held a silent salute as the casket passed through a covered walkway and into the church.

About 3,000 people in overflow seating outside watched the ceremony on a giant TV. Images of Bonaminio as a toddler, a boy, a soldier and a police officer flashed on screen during a video tribute.

Later, Gerri Bonaminio told mourners, "Now my Ryan is free and he'll never be hurt again."

His father, Joe, and sister, Nikki, also spoke while his older brother, Christopher, stood with them on stage.

The family and friends remembered Bonaminio as polite and patient, with a sense of humor. They recalled a small-statured teen who joined Jr. ROTC at Ramona High School in Riverside with his sights set on a law enforcement career.

Despite the intensity of his jobs, from dodging enemy fire overseas to patrolling the streets of Riverside, he held onto his boyish qualities. Bonaminio loved to paint and dress small military figurines, collect G.I. Joes and play video games. And always, there was a smile on his face.

Sgt. Doug Spencer, who served in Iraq with Bonaminio, recalled their unit patrolling in 130-degree heat and sleeping in the sand.

"There's Ryan walking around with a big smile on his face. He loved to serve his country, he loved to serve Riverside. He was a man of honor. He was a true American hero," he said.

"Today, Ryan, you don't salute this nation, this nation salutes you," Spencer said, snapping off a salute. "I love you, Ryan."

Story continues below
slain police Officer Ryan Bonaminio memorial
Mark Zaleski/The Press-Enterprise
Army personnel grieve at Officer Bonaminio's casket after the burial ceremony. The fallen officer served two Army tours in the Middle East before joining the Riverside force.

Sgt. Kevin Duxbury, who also served with Bonaminio in Iraq, said his friend was always one of the first to volunteer.

"At barely 20 he's still collecting G.I. Joes and playing video games, but there he was in downtown Baghdad with his game face on," Duxbury said.

The sergeant asked mourners to applaud Bonaminio. As one, they rose and clapped.

COMMUNITY IN SHOCK

On a clear, sun-warmed morning, bystanders gathered on the streets to watch the miles-long procession from the mortuary to the church and cemetery. They came for a sense of belonging and respect, with children and neighbors in folding chairs waving at police and somberly holding signs. Under any other circumstances, they would have been cheering.

Bonaminio's death prompted a huge outpouring of support not only because he was a well-liked and conscientious young man who served overseas and at home, but because the killing happened in his hometown, Chief Diaz said.

C.J. Wilkins, an Azusa police officer, said it was because Bonaminio likely was shot with his own weapon.

"Being hurt by what you carry to work every day, that's scary," he said.

GeanetteTrumball and her four children sat on a hillside above the church, listening to outside speakers, then waved balloons at the procession. Her 10-year-old son, Kurt, dreams of going into the military and then becoming a police officer, she said.

"We talk about being a mom and loving your son, and how you're honored that they want to protect people," she said.

Onlookers lined Orange Terrace Parkway near Van Buren Boulevard as the hearse moved to the cemetery. An American flag fluttered between the raised ladders of two firetrucks.

Stella Paramo, her two daughters and two nieces named each department as its cars passed and thanked the officers.

"This is just overwhelming and beautiful. I've never seen anything like it," said Michelle Banks, whose husband is a Riverside police sergeant.

Story continues below
slain Riverside police Officer Ryan Bonaminio memorial
Mark Zaleski/The Press-Enterprise
Joe Bonaminio and his wife, Gerri, shed tears after Gerri was given the flag that covered their son's casket. From left are Ryan's brother, Christopher, friend John Enriquez and sister, Nikki.

Officers waved to the crowd, and some took pictures as their squad cars passed. A female officer from the San Diego Police Department turned on her loudspeaker and said, "Thank you all for coming."

At the cemetery, under maple trees nearly bare of their last brittle leaves, a cordon of police officers stood shoulder-to-shoulder along the drive where the hearse arrived and along the curving walkway that led to the front of the amphitheater where the service took place.

END OF A JOURNEY

Kyle Cook, 27, of Riverside, came with friends, all of whom knew Bonaminio. Cook said he went on a couple of ride-alongs with another Riverside police officer, Ryan McHugh, who worked the same beat as Bonaminio. Wherever they were called, Cook said, Bonaminio was quick to back them up.

"He was there like 10 seconds after we got there," Cook said. "We stopped a (Chevy) S-10 that had some known gang members. I was a little scared, but to watch them work. ... They were just fearless."

Riverside police Chaplain Steve Ballinger likened Bonaminio's life to a leg of a relay race.

"I would say that Ryan has run a good race. He has placed that baton of life in our hands with his attitude. ... Ryan would say, 'Run.' "

Overhead, a Navy gunship flew past before seven other helicopters in a V-formation rattled through the air. One helicopter peeled off toward the east as the rest flew north.

Story continues below
slain police Officer Ryan Bonaminio memorial
Stan Lim/The Press-Enterprise
Riverside police Officers Scott Levesque, right, and Stacie Tedesco console each other at the end of Bonaminio funeral service.

A Los Angeles County sheriff's deputy led a riderless horse across the amphitheater's stage. Empty boots in the stirrups and a sword hung from the saddle all faced backwards, symbolizing the backward gaze of the fallen rider. A group of doves was released.

Joe Bonaminio then stepped forward and placed his hands on his son's casket. After a moment he stepped back, nodded his head and returned to his seat. After Chaplain Ballinger's closing remarks, Bonaminio stepped to the microphone.

"I want to say goodbye to my son," Bonaminio said. "Before I do that, I would like to thank each and every law enforcement agency that has come here today. It's a great honor that you bestow on my son."

He then turned to the casket.

"Yo, Brat," he said. "I've given you a candle to light the way on your journey."

He said he also had placed the book his son was reading and some green tea in the casket, and put a dollar in his pocket, "so they know you didn't die poor.

"There's 55 cents in there," he continued. "When you get to the end of your journey, your mother will be waiting, your father will be waiting, your brother will be waiting, your sister will be waiting. Please call home."

Staff writers Richard K. De Atley and Vanessa Franko contributed to this report.

ryan bonaminio, riverside police

Riverside police officer, Ryan Bonaminio, was killed while pursuing a hit-and-run suspect on November 7, 2010.

Special Section: The Death of Ryan Bonaminio

The Concord Coalition, Today gave high marks to a budget plan.. (Nov. 18, 2010) From the Concord Coalition...

WASHINGTON -- The Concord Coalition today gave high marks to a budget plan released by the Bipartisan Policy Center's Debt Reduction Task Force and encouraged elected officials and the American public to carefully consider its proposals. 

"This is a credible and comprehensive path to a more responsible federal budget," said Robert L. Bixby, Concord's executive director and a member of the bipartisan task force. "It demonstrates that when people with diverse perspectives commit themselves in good faith to negotiating a comprehensive plan to meet our nation's fiscal challenges, they can do it."

The task force today issued its final report, recommending spending caps, sweeping improvements in the tax system, and substantial changes in Medicare and Social Security. The goal would be to reduce and stabilize the federal debt below 60 percent of the economy.

To help strengthen the economy in the short term, the panel also advocates a one-year break in 2011 from the Social Security payroll tax for both employees and employers.

The task force included former White House officials, former members of Congress, former governors and others. It is separate from President Obama's bipartisan National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and Reform, which is scheduled to release its final report Dec. 1.

Last week the co-chairmen of the president's commission released draft proposals that Concord praised as a "valuable and sobering fiscal reality check."

Like those proposals, the plan released today by the Bipartisan Policy Center's task force can help the nation focus on the fundamental choices and trade-offs that will have to be made.

The task force's report illustrates the importance of considering all the available options during budget negotiations and recognizing that compromise will be essential to put the nation on a better fiscal and economic path.

"The Bipartisan Policy Center deserves great credit for putting together this task force," Bixby said, "and I know how hard every member of the panel -- particularly co-chairs Alice Rivlin and Pete Domenici -- worked to develop a strong, specific plan that could be useful to Congress and the country in
moving toward consensus."

"No doubt some people will be uncomfortable with some parts of this plan," Bixby added. "But it should be looked at as a negotiated package to which a group of people with a wide range of individual perspectives could agree."

The Concord Coalition urges any critics of the plan to do more than simply complain about the many difficult sacrifices that the task force has suggested.

"With a rapidly growing federal debt and entitlement programs headed for insolvency, painful sacrifices are unavoidable," Bixby said. "To be taken seriously, critics of this plan – or of any proposals  from the President's commission -- should offer credible alternatives to the provisions they
don't like.

They shouldn't act as if we can just keep coasting along with the status quo because, quite simply, we can no longer afford it."
 
# # #

The Concord Coalition is a national, grassroots organization dedicated to fiscal responsibility. Former U.S. Senators Warren B. Rudman (R-NH) and Bob Kerrey (D-NE) serve as its co-chairs and former U.S. Secretary of Commerce Peter G. Peterson serves as president. For more information, visit www.concordcoalition.org .

The Tea Party May Save Us Yet.. (by John Myers) Nov. 17, 2010

The Tea Party May Save Us Yet

November 17, 2010 by John Myers 

The Tea Party May Save Us Yet

There has been a huge sigh of relief in the corridors of Calgary's oil towers following the Republican victory in the mid-term election. The GOP win assures much-needed changes in the Federal government's energy policy; changes that will benefit American consumers as well as Canadian petroleum producers.

It seems certain that climate change legislation in the United States is dead for at least the next two years, and hopefully forever. That is good news for Alberta's oil sands industry, which has been facing an uphill battle against Greens inside the old Democrat-controlled Congress.

"I think the playing field for Canadian energy will be a lot more level now," said Republican David Wilkins, the Bush administration's last ambassador to Ottawa.

Former Canadian diplomat Colin Robertson agrees and says that while special interest groups will still keep up their lobbying efforts against oil sands, climate change legislation is DOA. That closes the casket on what could have become a border levy on Alberta's oil sands.

A Fresh Look For Oil Sands
While Canadians may hate guns and embrace universal healthcare, many are happy about the Tea Party's influence. This is true of Canadian petroleum executives who understood the threat of ousted Speaker of the House, Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.). They realize that the 112th Congress will have a far more balanced approach to petroleum. Incited by President BarackObama, Democrats had been making "clean energy" their mantra.

Finally, some sanity is restored. There is a growing realization that wind and solar power are incredibly expensive and are without significant infrastructure, and an understanding that neither will make a noticable dent in America's energy appetite before the end of this decade.

This truth didn't seem to faze House Democrats who wanted a national renewable-electricity standard. They were blissfully ignorant of a fundamental truth — that Green energy is more pie in the sky than it is juice on the grid.

Democrats also misunderstood America's growing dependence on Arab oil. Consider the Obama drilling moratorium in the Gulf of Mexico following the Deepwater Horizon disaster. Neither he nor House Democrats seem to comprehend that oil from the Gulf of Mexico was helping the U.S. reduce oil imports. And while the largely untested Bakken formation of the Dakotas and Montana is promising, it was Gulf Coast production that was making the difference.

Stopping The Greens Before It's Too Late
A more conservative Congress can take immediate steps to re-establish offshore oil drilling and open up oil exploration in Alaska. This cannot happen too soon, as America faces an immense energy crisis — one that the Obama administration has recklessly ignored.

The GOP gets it, especially the conservative wing of the Party, which understands that fossil fuels are and will remain essential to America's national security. Oil will account for more than 90 percent of U.S. transportation energy and more than two-thirds of U.S. electricity through the end of this decade. The newly elected conservatives promise to be an enormous improvement over the previous Congress, which was focused on strengthening the Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007; an act which Obama reinforced last year with stimulus money.

What most Americans don't realize is what folly taxpayer's money was being spent on. There is a hidden clause in the Energy Independence and Security Act which was signed into law in 2007. It is found within Section 526.

According to that section, all Federal agencies — with the exception of NASA — are prohibited from purchasing carbon-intensive unconventional fuels:

"No Federal agency shall enter into a contract for procurement of an alternative or synthetic fuel, including a fuel produced from non-conventional petroleum sources, for any mobility-related use, other than for research or testing, unless the contract specifies that the life-cycle greenhouse gas emissions associated with the production and combustion of the fuel supplied under the contract must, on an ongoing basis, be less than or equal to such emissions from the equivalent conventional fuel produced from conventional petroleum sources."

The U.S. military could not get its fuel from Alberta's oil sands and instead had to rely on oil from nations like Saudi Arabia and Venezuela, two countries renowned for their grassroots hatred of the U.S.

Last month, Energy & Capital pointed out what an obstacle this is, because America's military is the world's single largest purchaser of crude oil. Most anyone outside the Democratic Party will take Alberta over Arabia.

That is because most people have some common sense. They understand that having a strategic supply of oil next door in a democratic nation that shares a common language and core values is a good thing. But "most people" does not include Pelosi or Obama.

An Early Thanksgiving
Thank Heaven for the GOP's victory. Without it, Obama would have been free to sign a climate bill that would have targeted Canada's oil sands industry. Instead, Obama has been forced to admit that his hopes to put a price on the cost of carbon dioxide emissions — which he and the Greens blame for global warming — will be put on hold for at least the next two years. If you drive a car or heat your home you have to say: Hallelujah and pass the petroleum!

As you know, most Republicans campaigned against a so-called Cap-and-Trade bill that would have put a ceiling on U.S. climate pollution. We have a President that made "Going Green" a priority right after socialized medicine. Obama's Cap-and-Trade bill was in fact passed by the House, but stalled in the Senate because it was rightfully branded harmful to the U.S. economy by conservatives and others who were not corrupt or feebleminded.

Energy Injustice Derailed 
Obama has not given up on saving the environment. The President said he will push for more piecemeal incentives for developing alternative energies that could help the U.S. reduce its "carbon footprint."

The Greens may get their way if Obama continues forward with his economic policies. A recession turned depression would certainly reduce America's carbon footprint. It might even make the most radical of the Greens happy.

If you think I exaggerate, consider KAIROS, a coalition of half a dozen large liberal church groups in Canada that includes the United Church, some Catholics, Mennonites and Quakers. They have a staff of more than 20 and an annual budget that exceeds $4 million. Their largest project is called Energy Justice.

According to their Web site: "KAIROS is in the midst of Re-Energize: Time For A Carbon Sabbath, a three-year campaign for personal, community, and political change."

You might think that Canadian Christian groups might be worried about the lack of democracy or even women's rights in big Arab oil-exporting countries, some of which are known to finance terror groups like al-Qaida. Instead KAIROS, which unbelievably gets $1.5 million per year from the Canadian Federal government, has set its sights on something it considers far more evil: Alberta's oil sands.

What is most frightening is that environmental groups like KAIROS have plenty of allies, including Obama, Pelosi and Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.).

Liberty For All
And while many Canadians decry American conservative policies, Canada, too, is reaping the rewards of the conservative revolution spreading within the U.S. Canada is like American liberals who oppose handguns yet sleep better at night knowing that criminals are wary of breaking into their homes because at least a few of the neighbors are packing pistols.

Both Canada and the U.S. need Alberta's oil sands. Canada has roughly 180 billion barrels of proven oil reserves, second only to Saudi Arabia. More than 95 percent of these reserves are oil sands deposits in Alberta. In the past decade, Canada's oil production has steadily risen as new oil sands have come on-stream to replace aging, mature fields. This has been fortuitous to the United States, whose own aging fields have been in drastic decline. That the previous Congress thwarted this marriage of necessity borders on treason.

Next week I will be giving thanks with my family that there is new hope with the new Congress; hope sparked by the conservative ideals of the Tea Party, which are arresting the energy idiocy that is Obama and his Democrats.

Yours for real wealth and good health,

John Myers
Myers' Energy and Gold Report

Did You Know Your Airport Can Opt Out of TSA Molestations? (by Erick Erickson) November 16, 2010

Did You Know Your Airport Can Opt Out of TSA Molestations?


Byron York has good news for people around the country.

Your local airport can opt out of having the Transportation Safety Administration handle security at your local airport. Instead, you can contract out to the private sector. It was one of the ingenious and little noticed provisions the Republicans dropped in the post-9/11 legislation creating the TSA.

With a move to unionize the TSA and the TSA groping 3 year olds and nuns in nutty security theater, opt-ing out in favor of free market competence sounds like a great idea. Oh, and Congress will cover the payments to the TSA replacement.

Practicing what I preach, I am the Chairman of the Public Properties Committee of the City of Macon, Georgia. As such, I chair the committee that oversees the Middle Georgia Regional Airport. I will be drafting legislation to have my local airport opt-out of having the TSA grope passengers.

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

SARAH PALIN: An open letter to Republican Freshmen Members of Congress (Nov. 16, 2010)

SARAH PALIN: An Open Letter to Republican Freshmen Members of Congress
By Sarah Palin
Published November 13, 2010 | FoxNews.com



Congratulations to all of you for your contribution to this historic election, and for the contributions I am certain you will make to our country in the next two years. Your victory was hard fought, and the success belongs entirely to you and the staff and volunteers who spent countless hours working for this chance to put government back on the side of the people. Now you will come to Washington to serve your nation and leave your mark on history by reining in government spending, preserving our freedoms at home, and restoring America’s leadership abroad.

Some of you have asked for my thoughts on how best to proceed in the weeks and months ahead and how best to advance an agenda that can move our country forward. I have a simple answer: stick to the principles that propelled your campaigns.

When you take your oath to support and defend our Constitution and to faithfully discharge the duties of your office, remember that present and future generations of “We the People” are counting on you to stand by that oath. Never forget the people who sent you to Washington.

GOP Assault on Federal Pay Puts Obama in Politically Difficult Position (By Stephen Clark) Nov. 16, 2010

GOP Assault on Federal Pay Puts Obama in Politically Difficult Position
By Stephen Clark
Published November 16, 2010 | FoxNews.com


ADVERTISEMENT
President Obama is stuck between a rock and a hard place, as newly empowered House Republicans unleash a torrent of proposals to shrink the size of government and following a series of reports that show federal workers increasing in numbers and salary.

Obama may have to choose between satisfying his base or placating independents who moved overwhelming into the Republican camp in the midterm elections two weeks ago based in part on their frustration over the growth of government in the past two years.

While slashing the government will be a top priority for Republicans in the next Congress, 60 percent of the federal workforce is represented by the labor unions that helped sweep the president into power two years ago.

"The calculation he has to make is how much he wants to bring that swing vote back," said Matrick Masters, a national labor expert and a professor of business and political science at Wayne State University.

"One of the ways is to go after government issues. The calculation he's going to make is how much damage it's going to do to the base," Masters told FoxNews.com. "He's got to realize he's got a difficult situation."

Already a flurry of proposals have been offered to slash spending on government functionaries.

Speaker-in-waiting John Boehner has called for a freeze in hiring and pay raises. Incoming House Majority Leader Eric Cantor said his federal payroll plan could save taxpayers $35 billion.

Rep. Jason Chaffetz, the top Republican on the subcommittee with oversight of the federal workforce who is likely to become the panel's next chairman, wants a 10 percent across-the-board pay cut.

Chaffetz told FoxNews.com on Tuesday that the federal payroll has grown by an additional 141,000 federal workers -- not counting Census employees, postal workers and uniformed members of the military -- since Obama took office. The president wants to hire 125,000 more workers.

Including compensation, the current cost of the federal workforce is $447 billion, he said.

"Somehow, some way, we're going to have to learn how to survive on just $400 billion," he said, adding that his proposal would give each agency and department discretion in how to reach a 10 percent reduction.

Even the chairman of Obama's bipartisan federal deficit commission has recommended a three-year freeze on federal salaries and a 10 percent cut in the number of federal workers as part of a draft report that some lawmakers say is dead on arrival.

But the proposals run counter to Obama's plan to give a 1.4 percent across-the-board pay raise to 2.1 million federal workers next fiscal year.

A USA Today analysis last week showed that the number of federal workers earning $150,000 or more per year has soared tenfold in the past five years and doubled since Obama took office.

But the American Federation of Government Employees, the largest union for federal employees and a staunch supporter of the president, rejects the notion that federal workers make more than their private-sector counterparts.

"There has been a concerted campaign by corporate-influenced groups and others to introduce the dangerous lie that federal employees are 'overpaid' relative to their private sector counterparts," union president John Gage said in a written statement.

Gage cited statistics from the Labor Bureau that showed federal salaries lag behind those in the private sector for almost all jobs in almost all locations throughout the U.S.

And AFGE spokeswoman Christine Erling said AFGE "vigorously opposes any efforts to freeze federal hiring and cut federal employees' pay."

"We have made and will continue to make our opposition to these types of punitive proposals known to the Obama administration as well as to the Congress," Erling said in an e-mail to FoxNews.com.

Supporters of federal pay rates note that the highest paid federal workers, such as doctors, lawyers and nuclear engineers, are earning well below market price. But the Heritage Foundation has estimated that taxpayers would save $47 billion if federal workers were paid at the same rate as private sector employees.

The White House did not respond to an e-mail seeking an interview, but unions, which represent more than 600,000 federal employees and total about 60 percent of the government workforce, put Obama in a politically difficult position if he wanted to seek a compromise with Republicans on the issue.

Labor was critical in mobilizing voters and getting them to cast ballots for Obama in 2008 but turnout dropped in the 2010 midterm in part because many union workers didn't see Obama go to bat for their initiatives, Masters said.

"I don't think those memories are lost upon him," he said. "He will need the support of labor in 2012."

Masters said that Obama will be under "intense" pressure to freeze hiring and pay in the federal workforce.

"It's a relatively easy thing to do -- a stroke of the pen and say, I'm going to freeze hiring, cap pay, and everybody is going to say, hip hip hooray -- jump for joy and not think about what it means," he said.

But, he suggested, Obama may just want to try to explain why he opposes a hiring freeze.

"What are you going to do if you have 1,000 air traffic controllers retire tomorrow morning? What are you going to do? But you don't want planes to be delayed. What's the economic consequence of that?" he asked by way of example. "It's going to have some impact."

In-State Tuition upheld for illegal immigrants (by Nanette Asimov, Chronicle Staff Writer) Nov. 16, 2010

In-state tuition upheld for illegal immigrants

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

California's Supreme Court became the first in the country Monday to affirm the right of illegal immigrants to pay the same college tuition as state residents, rather than the higher out-of-state rate.

The ruling upholds a 2002 state law that lets students pay in-state tuition at public colleges and universities if they attended a California high school for at least three years before graduating.

Civil rights groups, university officials and undocumented students themselves applauded the ruling, which may impact thousands of people living in the United States illegally who apply to California colleges each year.

California's tuition law affects not only undocumented students, but also anyone who meets the high school criteria, such as boarding school students whose parents live in other states or graduate students who grew up in California but lost residency by going to college somewhere else.

Nine states have similar laws.

Of the 2,000 or so University of California students who benefit from the law, about 400 are undocumented, according to a UC survey. Other state universities say they don't track students' status.

"Through their hard work and perseverance, these students have earned the opportunity to attend UC," said Mark Yudof, UC's president. "Their accomplishments should not be disregarded or their futures jeopardized."

Nonresidents sue

In 2005, 42 people who live outside California sued UC, arguing that the state's tuition law gave illegal residents an unfair advantage over legal U.S. residents when applying to college. Federal law prohibits such advantages for undocumented students "on the basis of residence within a state."

But Monday's ruling said the California law is not based on residence, but on such factors as how many years a student attended high school.

"If Congress had intended to prohibit states entirely from making unlawful aliens eligible for in-state tuition, it could easily have done so," the court ruled.

Attorney Kris Kobach, who represents the plaintiffs, called the ruling a "very weak opinion." He said he will ask the U.S. Supreme Court to review the case.

Kobach, recently elected Kansas secretary of state, co-wrote Arizona's immigration law requiring police to question anyone they suspect of living in the country illegally. He said California's taxpayers lose millions of dollars each year because the state doesn't require undocumented students to pay the out-of-state rate.

But UC Berkeley sophomore Uriel Rivera, who entered the United States illegally at age 14, said taxpayers lose nothing because students like him have enough trouble paying the in-state rate.

Difference in tuition

At UC, state residents pay $11,300 in tuition a year; nonresidents pay $34,000. State and federal law prohibit illegal residents from receiving public grants or scholarships.

So Rivera and other undocumented students scramble for private scholarships. He wants to become a history teacher.

Today, however, Rivera is so far behind on tuition that the campus library won't even let him take out books.

Still, he said, he feels "happiness and relief" at the ruling. Without the tuition law, he said, "our chances of getting a college education would be nonexistent."

The case is Martinez vs. Regents of the University of California. The ruling can be found at sfg.ly/arNGH3.

E-mail Nanette Asimov at nasimov@sfchronicle.com.

http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2010/11/16/MNG61GCDH0.DTL

This article appeared on page A - 1 of the San Francisco Chronicle